the.com/tin ear

The inability to tell a melody from a cry for help.

means A lack of sensitivity to music, language, tone, or nuance — someone who literally can't hear when something sounds wrong.

from American slang from the early 20th century, built on a simple metaphor: tin is a cheap, dull metal, nothing like the fine, sensitive apparatus of a real ear. First used for people who couldn't carry a tune or judge music, it spread to cover anyone deaf to tone of any kind — in writing, diplomacy, or conversation — as if their ear were made of cheap metal instead of flesh.

origin
tin was once slang for cheap and worthless
applies to
music, tact, diplomacy, apology timing
not deafness
ears work fine, judgment does not
classic sign
singing confidently and wrongly at karaoke
the.com · every word