the.com/begging the question
An argument that assumes its own conclusion, not a question that demands asking.
means A logical fallacy where the conclusion is smuggled into the premise, so the argument proves nothing — it just restates itself in a circle.
from The phrase translates the Latin 'petitio principii,' itself a rendering of a term from Aristotle's logic meaning roughly 'assuming the starting point.' 'Petitio' was mistranslated into English as 'begging' (as in 'requesting'), giving us the odd image of an argument that 'begs' — asks you to simply grant — the very point it's supposed to prove. The modern casual use, where people say it to mean 'this raises the question,' is a popular but logically unrelated drift from the original technical meaning — language slipping its own leash.
- original meaning
- circular reasoning, from Latin petitio principii
- common misuse
- people use it to mean raises the question
- example
- lying is wrong because honesty is right
- pedants beware
- the misuse is now so common dictionaries list it